Skip to main content

Five Questions That The Indian Operation in Myanmar Raises


GUWAHATI: Khaplang faction of National Socialist Council of Nagaland (NSCN-K) on Wednesday termed the reports of it suffering massive casualties in and around Myanmar as "baseless". The outfit has challenged the Indian Army to display the bodies of cadres killed in the attack Read <<more>>>

1. Why is Myanmar denying that the operation took place within its territory?
This is confusing. According to the Indian account, the Indian army struck militants at bases within Myanmar’s territory. Myanmar, on Wednesday, denied this claim. In a Facebook post, Zaw Htay, director of Myanmar’s presidential office, said, “According to the information sent by Tatmadaw (Myanmar army) battalions on the ground, we have learned that the military operation was performed on the Indian side at India-Myanmar border.” “Myanmar will not accept any foreigner who attacks neighbouring countries in the back and creates problems by using our own territory,” he added.
Given that India and Myanmar have a long standing agreement, even authorising the two armies to cross the border to combat terrorism, why is Myanmar denying the Indian government’s very categorical claim? Is it embarrassed and worried about the major publicity India seems to be giving to the ‘hot pursuit’ by the special forces, or is there more to it?
2. Why is the NSCN-K denying that any of its members were killed?
The Indian account states that the NSCN-K -- The National Socialist Council of Nagaland – Khaplang, the group behind the Manipur attack were targeted. The NSCN-K, however, denies this. In fact, the group has outrightly denied that it even has camps in the area that the Indian army says the operation took place.
“There were no NSCN-K camps in areas claimed by the Indian army,” the rebels reportedly said. The militants added that the attack was "completely false" and said the reports were efforts by the Indian army "to save their reputation". The release further challenged the army to show the bodies of cadres who were supposedly killed in the attack.
Further, the rebel group said areas shown by television channels as camp locations were "non-existent" in the borders areas. "The topography shown on TVs are all non-existent. We do not have a well-maintained footpath or the pine garden that were shown," the NSCN (K) added.
The answer to the question regarding why the NSCN-K is denying the Indian army’s claims is fairly straightforward, as it does not want to demoralise its cadres. But the denial does raise the question.
3. Who were the people killed?
Combat, whether national or cross-border, is governed by standard operating procedures aimed to prevent human rights violations and civilian casualties. However, given the secrecy surrounding the Myanmar operation (for good reason and not-so-good reason), there is a lot of ambiguity regarding the number (and nature) of people killed. Was it between 20 and 50? Was it 100? Further, who were these people? Were they all military aged males? Were they all armed? How did the Indian army ensure only “militants” were killed?
4. What about China?
The operation fails to address one of the most crucial factors governing militancy in India’s northeast: China.
Rahul Bedi wrote in The Citizen: “Intelligence sources said Chinese arms began trickling into the region around 2005 via Bangladesh and reports on last week’s ambush indicate that sophisticated weaponry, including grenade launchers, was employed in the attack.
The Chinese are believed to have established an armaments factory in Myanmar, which reportedly is supplying arms to militant groups operating in the northeast.
If it is indeed, confirmed that rebel weaponry was sourced from China it would seriously embarrass the Modi government, unctuously cosying up to Beijing.
It would also present a dilemma for Modi with the possibility of the relatively dormant insurgencies re-igniting. There is enough local resentment for the varied militant groups, especially in Manipur, to tap into that could well turn the region into a violent tinder box.”
If the Myanmar Operation served as a “lesson” to India’s neighbours who aid and shelter terrorists, then it is indeed worth exploring what the Modi government has to say on China’s role in fostering militancy in India’s northeast, whilst the Prime Minister cosies up to Xi Jinping.
5. And now what?
From 2001 to March 2015, the NSCN(K) had a ceasefire with the Indian government. Although the talks achieved little, every year, the ceasefire was extended. Does India’s decided course of action mean that any prospect of negotiations are off the table?
Most importantly, the above question demonstrates the core of the Naga problem. It relates to the larger question of the roots of the militancy in Nagaland, where a number of rebel groups are fighting for a unified Nagaland. Addressing militancy in any region usually relates to root causes -- social, economic, political, and cultural.
The only solution to militancy is through an understanding of the root causes. This can only be made possible through negotiations (made possible in turn by a ceasefire). While a military operation may achieve short-term gains, it will accentuate long-term costs by increasing alienation amongst an already disenchanted population. This is not to say that a military operation holds no validity, but rather, to ensure transparency as well as addressing questions relating to a future course of action.
Instead of vocalising patriotism through the facade of military action and retribution, it is perhaps worth asking: now what? What are the implications of the breakdown of the ceasefire and the Indian government’s choice of action on the ethnic conflict in Nagaland? This is the most crucial question that demands an answer.
http://www.thecitizen.in

  • Dunya News: Myanmar operation led to change in ...

    dunyanews.tv/.../Myanmar-operation-led-to-change-in...
    Myanmar operation led to change in approaches of countries, say Indian Defense Minister 2015-06-11 12:47 ...
  • Unanswered Questions Related to Indian Army's Myanmar ...

    www.ibtimes.co.in/unanswered-questions-related-india...
    1 day ago
    Even the photographs of the Indian Army involved in Myanmar military operation came into question.
  • Indian Army Crosses Myanmar Border to Hit Northeast Rebels

    www.bloomberg.com/.../indian-army-attacks-militants-...
    3 days ago
    India's army entered Myanmar to strike militants involved in an attack last week that killed 20 soldiers, the ...
  • How Indian Army's Rare Cross-Border Op in Myanmar Killed ...

    www.ibtimes.co.in/indian-armys-rare-cross-border-op-...
    2 days ago
    The Myanmar government had on Monday given its assent to the Indian Army's operationin the dense ...
  • Indian Media Fooling Everyone With Fake Pictures of ...

    www.zemtv.com/.../indian-media-fooling-everyone-wi...
    Indian Media Fooling Everyone With Fake Pictures of Myanmar Military Operation. Posted On June 11, 2015 ...
  • Manipur ambush: Indian Army hits back, kills insurgents in ...

    www.youtube.com/watch?v=FlTS7KcVmNk
    3 days ago - Uploaded by Zee News
    In a pro-active strike, Army Tuesday carried out an operation along the India-Myanmar border inflicting ...
  • Everything You Wanted To Know About Indian Army's ...

    www.youtube.com/watch?v=ENA7MS6MAEQ
    2 days ago - Uploaded by IndiaTV
    Everything You Wanted To Know About IndianArmy's Operation In Myanmar SUBSCRIBE toIndia TV Here ...
  • Pakistani media Is painic On Indian Myanmar operation-10 ...

    www.youtube.com/watch?v=66QRJnLI6oc
    2 days ago - Uploaded by RayMiya
    Pakistani media Is painic On Indian Myanmar operation-10 june 2015 Subscribe For More Leatest news ...
  • Militants Enter India to Avenge Army's Myanmar Operation ...

    www.ibtimes.co.in/after-myanmar-op-militants-enter-i...
    1 day ago
    Even as the Indian Army is being hailed for itsoperation along the Myanmar border that saw many Naga ...
  • Myanmar Operation: 'Those Who Fear India's New Posture ...

    www.ibtimes.co.in › Society › Politics
    1 day ago
    Indian Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar took a dig at Pakistan following India's militaryoperation against ...
  • Popular posts from this blog

    A historic moment in the Arab world

    لحظة تاريخية في العالم العربي
    As a democratic revolution led by tech-empowered young people sweeps the Arab world, Wadah Khanfar, Al Jazeera's director-general, shares a profoundly optimistic view of what's happening in Egypt, Tunisia, Libya and beyond. In the first talk posted online from the TED 2011 conference in California, Khanfar describes the powerful moment when people realised they could step out of their homes and ask for change. "كما ثورة ديمقراطية بقيادة الشباب التكنولوجيا ذات صلاحيات تجتاح العالم العربي ، وضاح خنفر ، الجزيرة المدير العام والأسهم وجهة نظر متفائلة بشكل كبير ما يحدث في مصر وتونس وليبيا وخارجها. وفي اول حديث له نشر على الانترنت من مؤتمر تيد 2011 في ولاية كاليفورنيا ، خنفر يصف لحظة قوية عند الناس أدركت أنها لا يمكن الخروج من منازلهم ونطلب من أجل التغيير."
    http://www.ted.com/talks/wadah_khanfar_a_historic_moment_in_the_arab_world.html This talk was given on March 1, 2011 in Long Beach, California. TED 2011 is taking place between March 1 and Mar…

    Corona & Attitude of Ulema of Pakistan - Point to Ponder

    Faith is entirely a personal matter, which cannot be measured or quantified. Anyone who declares to believe in 6 Fundamentals and 5 Pillars of Islam is considered as a Muslim even if he lacks in practice.
     کرونا اور علماء پاکستان کا رویہ - لمحہ فکریہ:پاکستان اس وقت  تک ترقی نہیں کر سکتا  جب تک ہم اس جاہل ، مزہبی انتہا پسند طبقے کی اس زہنیت سےچھٹکارا  نہیں حاصل  کر لیتے جو مساجد ، مذہب کو کنٹرول کرکہ  زیادہ جاہل عوام کو گمراہ  کرتے ہیں۔  اسلام کو ان جہلا کے شکنجے بچایا جانا صروری ہے۔ .....[....]
    We find many people looking "more Muslim" than others due to their outlook and activities in display, yet it's not a measuring  tool for their level of faith , which is only known to Allah. However they consider ONLY themselves  to be entitled to  exercise control on religion, which is contested because authenticity of any opinion on religious matter is conditional to the reference and authority from Holy Scripture. 
    Allah has not authorized anyone to present their personal opinions …

    SalaamOne NetWork

    SalaamOneسلامisa nonprofit e-Forum to promote peace among humanity, through understanding and tolerance of religions, cultures & other human values.
    علم اور افہام و تفہیم کے لئے ایک غیر منافع بخش ای فورم ہے. علم،انسانیت، مذہب، سائنس، سماج، ثقافت، اخلاقیات اورروحانیت امن کے لئے.اس فورم کو آفتاب خان،  آزاد محقق اور مصنف نے منظم کیا ہے. تحقیقی کام دس سال سے "ڈیفنس جرنل" میں تسلسل سے چھپ رہا ہے جو کہ بلاگز، ویب سائٹ، سوشل میڈیا، میگزین، ویڈیو چننل اور برقی کتابوں کی صورت میں دستیاب ہے.اس  نیٹ ورک  کو اب تک لاکھوں افراد وزٹ کر چکے ہیں-


    The enterprise is managed by Aftab Khan, a freelance researcher and writer. His work and collection is available in the form of e-Books. articles, magazines, videos, posts at social media, blogs & video channels. The  Forum is open to  all the rational, peace loving  people of any faith, gender or race. You may join at social media , invite your friends and share the stuff. The NetWork It has been visited by over  Millions of people around th…